Do Not Feed the Animals
Reading the Asuncion article "Platform Affordances, Produsage, and the Attention Economy: From Red (Taylor’s Version) to The Life of a Showgirl" (2026) and its discussion regarding an artist's intentional and strategic work to navigate "aesthetic, affective and algorithmic demands" made me think about the ways social media is deployed to cultivate an audience.
That, in turn, led me to various research articles focused on gaming culture and its impact on users - both positive and negative.
I asked AI if there is a universally-recognized "toxicity index" for various gaming platforms and communities. While it explained why there is not, it provided an overview of platforms most frequently associated with toxicity concerns (below).
As parents and grandparents, it is incredibly important that we all educate ourselves about these issues. While many of the articles from gamers I read emphasized the sense of community provided by many platforms, the risks and dangers remain and guidance needs to be emphasized.
Toxic communities thrive on interaction. I don't think regulation can keep pace with the evolution in manipulating human behavior to suit their goal of increased engagement and monetization.
Perhaps the most effective way to combat a toxic game culture is to starve it out, which begins by recognizing when the animal reveals itself.
We need to then know what the animal looks like, sounds like and "eats". Interactive gaming platforms are a new species, in ways both good and bad. We need to acknowledge that and not blindly assume they are always harmless entertainment.


Hi! I kind of touched on the digital communities I was part of when I was younger (Xbox Live) and now (Reddit) in my posts this week. My students play Roblox and Fortnite, and I'm unaware of the gaming culture they are involved in. You made a good point about presuming that everything is fine online and that the behavior amongst users in those environments is being moderated. I remember back in the mid-to-late 2000's that the only moderation occurring by game developers was cursing. Bullying, targeting, and the 'griefing' you mentioned could still be prevalent unless you report a user, which was a process, especially for younger users.
ReplyDeleteYes, its a bit terrifying to me that parents often are happy to have the kids distracted and quiet by playing these games ... which are really entire digital communities ... and not aware of what they are exposed to. I may have done the same when I was a busy parent with kids at home but now am learning more and more about how impactful these spaces are. I mentored a young girl at an elementary school who kept mentioning Roblox (which I originally took to be RoadBlocks :)) and how she wanted money to be able to upgrade her character online. She shared how the other players made fun of her characters' dress or lack of accessories. She was pretty light-hearted about it but I was shocked to find out this was a "thing" ... in 2nd grade! There is a LOT going on.
Delete